Ohio Whitetail Deer Hunts

The large glass windows allow you to see the coveted Ohio whitetail bucks moving through the timber line and across the meadow. The large deck on the front is a great place to sit and reflect on your hunt while enjoying the picturesque view.

Bowhunting Ohio whitetail deer can be one of the most exhilarating experiences an outdoorsman can have. You will be out in the woods during some of the prettiest times in the year, when the leaves are changing and the weather is still nice and warm.

Here, the bow hunter has nearly four full months to pursue that trophy; with the rut typically running from the last week of October through the latter part of November.

You will have access to our game from our elevated platforms, strategically located so the deer can’t see you and your scent is more dissipated. Our bowhunting packages last 5 full days beginning on Monday and ending on Friday.

Gun Hunting

The gun hunter has one week to collect his deer with a choice of weapons: shotguns, muzzleloaders, and certain handguns. There is also a muzzleloader season in January when the deer are coming together for the winter. This time of year can be quite cold; so, make sure you bring plenty of warm clothes! 

All gun hunts are conducted to suit each hunter’s preference.

You can sit on the stand and wait for that trophy buck to come in as there are many hunters out that keep the deer moving.

Or your guide can combine the sitting with some small drives to help get the deer moving.

Our gun hunting packages last 5 full days beginning on Monday and ending on Friday.

All the hunts below include meals and lodging:

1 or 2 day hunt0-130 Class Whitetail$1,495

2 day hunt130-140 Class Whitetail$2,495

2.5 day hunt140-150 Class Whitetail$3,495

2.5 day hunt150-160 Class Whitetail$4,495

2.5 day hunt160-170 Class Whitetail$5,495

3 day hunt170-180 Class Whitetail$6,495

3 day hunt180-190 Class Whitetail$7,495

3 day hunt190-200 Class Whitetail$8,995

3 day hunt200-210 Class Whitetail$10,995

Fair Chase Private Land Hunts$500/d - $2,495/w

Bow Hunting on Your OwnCall for pricing

Hunting Packages Policy

50% deposit is required to book a hunt.

Deposits are non-refundable.

Balance is due upon completion of hunt by cashier's check, money order or cash.

All state and local laws must be followed on all hunts.

Fees include lodging, meals, preparation of your trophy for taxidermy, and airport pickup from (Columbus or Akron Airport).

Fees do NOT include your hunting license (Private Land Hunts and Ohio Residents).

Stay At Your Home Away From Home

At our new 6 bedroom, 3000 square foot lodge you will feel right at home all the time.

The lodge sits on top of one of our majestic hills overlooking the ponds and hunting area. It has been designed with your convenience in mind so it can complement your overall stay.

The inside features an open timber design with high ceilings exposing beams in the large great room. There is a comfortable dining area along with a sitting area with a fireplace where you can relax after a day in the field. 

The large glass windows allow you to see the coveted Ohio whitetail bucks moving through the timber line and across the meadow. The large deck on the front is a great place to sit and reflect on your hunt while enjoying the picturesque view.

Other Things to Do While In the Area

At Starkey Hollow Whitetails you will find a wide range of extra activities available. If you have special requests that are not listed below, please discuss them with your hosts. As it is our pleasure to make your stay a memorable one! 

Tours Available

Although a tour can be arranged any time of the year, autumn in Amish Country is a special time! It is the greatest opportunity to explore the area’s beauty and experience some of its most popular destinations. Like an artist’s canvas of bright vibrant colors, the fall foliage is at its peak with a variety of hues. 

Amish & Mennonite Heritage Center

Your first stop in Amish Country! 

Berlin Main St. Merchants

Berlin, the heart of Amish Country! Berlin offers an array of more than 50, restaurants and attractions that will make your stay memorable! 

Breitenbach Wine Cellars

The best of Amish Country! Sample over 30 of their award winning wines. Large gift shop! 

Lehman's & Mt. Hope Hardware

A trip to the past makes an excellent present. Visit the newly expanded old-time general store and see thousands of products you probably thought they quit making years ago. 

Links to view Amish activities available 

http://www.oacountry.com/ 

http://www.ohioamishcountry.com/

Other Activities Available

Pro Football Hall of Fame in Canton, Ohio

Since opening in 1963, the Pro Football Hall of Fame has grown in both size and stature. Today, the Hall of Fame stands as a shining tribute to the men who have made professional football America’s most popular sport. 

http://www.profootballhof.com/

Ogle bay Park in Wheeling, West Virginia

Nestled amidst the beauty of the West Virginia's mountains Ogle bay offers 1700 acres of relaxation and recreation. Choose from dozens of activities to please a variety of discriminating tastes including Oglebayfest, the area’s premier fall festival. Ogle bay is home to one of America's largest holiday light shows, the Winter Festival of Lights. Each November and December, this six-mile driving show dazzles visitors with over a million lights on a six-mile drive displayed over 300 acres. 

http://www.oglebay-resort.com/

Cabela’s Store in Wheeling, West Virginia

Schedule a shopping trip to Cabela’s, the Worlds Foremost Outfitter.

http://www.cabelas.com/

Longaberger Homestead in Frazeysburg, Ohio

The Longaberger Homestead is a shopping and dining destination for the entire family! They have so much to offer that you may want to spend a whole day. Different activities can include: Basket-making Experience Tour to see the talented basket-makers, the Factory Store, where retired, revered and respected Longaberger products are available, and/or the Make A Basket Shop™ where you can weave your very own basket. 

http://www.longaberger.com/homestead.aspx

Arrangements can be made for any of the above activities and/or other personal requests as non-hunting guests are always welcomed and have as much fun as the hunter. Daily non-hunting fees may apply.

Hunt ID: OH-W-Deer-All-Newcomerstown-SHW

{BreezingForms:Hunt_Special_Information_Request_Form}